SPORTANALYST
FootballBaseballBasketballIce hockey
ENFRES
  1. Home
  2. MLB
  3. St. Louis Cardinals vs Pittsburgh Pirates

St. Louis Cardinals 5–1 Pittsburgh Pirates: match recap

STLSt. Louis CardinalsLWLLL5
PITPittsburgh PiratesWWWWW1

FinalMLB · Start Sep 23, 2026, 10:40 PM UTC · Venue: PNC Park

St. Louis Cardinals and Pittsburgh Pirates finished 5–1 (MLB) on September 23, 2026. Below: the form, standings and head-to-head record both teams took into the game.

Start your 7-day free trial→Get the app · Google Play

then from $4.99/mo billed yearly

FREE RECAP

Match recap

St. Louis used a three-run fifth inning to break open a tight game and cruise past Pittsburgh 5-1. The Cardinals' balanced attack out-hit the Pirates 7-3, erasing a solo homer from Brandon Lowe.

Matthew Liberatore worked three efficient innings, surrendering only a Brandon Lowe solo shot, while the St. Louis lineup chipped away early with a run in the first on a Masyn Winn single. The game turned for good in the fifth when the Cardinals plated three runs off Pirates reliever Brandon Eisert, keyed by a JJ Wetherholt walk and a Leo Bernal RBI knock. Pittsburgh's offense, save for Lowe's blast, managed just two more hits and never threatened, leaving just two men on base for the game.

Key factors

  • St. Louis strung together 7 hits and drew 2 walks, building a .368 team average that overwhelmed Pittsburgh's 3-hit, 0-walk attack.
  • Pittsburgh's bullpen imploded in the fifth, with Brandon Eisert allowing 3 earned runs in 0.2 IP to turn a 2-1 edge into a 5-1 deficit.

The Analyst's verdict

St. Louis demonstrated the value of consistent contact and timely hitting, while Pittsburgh's lack of offensive depth beyond Lowe's power was exposed. The Cardinals' ability to draw walks and avoid strikeouts gives them a repeatable formula against similar pitching.

Matchup edge

Form edge: Pittsburgh Pirates, 5-0 in the last 5 games against 1-4 for St. Louis Cardinals.

Matchup to watch: St. Louis Cardinals’ attack (index 100) against Pittsburgh Pirates’ defence (index 102).

Matchup to watch: Pittsburgh Pirates’ attack (index 107) against St. Louis Cardinals’ defence (index 104).

Recent form: last 5

St. Louis Cardinals: 1 win and 4 losses in the last 5, with 16 runs scored and 28 conceded.

St. Louis Cardinals
Sep 22, 2026at Pittsburgh PiratesL0–2
Sep 20, 2026vs Washington NationalsW5–3
Sep 19, 2026vs Washington NationalsL5–8
Sep 18, 2026vs Washington NationalsL1–9
Sep 16, 2026vs San Francisco GiantsL5–6

Pittsburgh Pirates: 5 wins and 0 losses in the last 5, with 27 runs scored and 17 conceded.

Pittsburgh Pirates
Sep 22, 2026vs St. Louis CardinalsW2–0
Sep 20, 2026vs Kansas City RoyalsW4–3
Sep 19, 2026vs Kansas City RoyalsW6–5
Sep 18, 2026vs Kansas City RoyalsW8–5
Sep 17, 2026vs Milwaukee BrewersW7–4

Results before kickoff, newest first.

Head-to-head

In the last 5 meetings on record, St. Louis Cardinals won 1, Pittsburgh Pirates won 4.

Sep 22, 2026Pittsburgh Pirates2–0St. Louis Cardinals
Aug 30, 2026St. Louis Cardinals4–5Pittsburgh Pirates
Aug 29, 2026St. Louis Cardinals2–6Pittsburgh Pirates
Aug 28, 2026St. Louis Cardinals4–1Pittsburgh Pirates
May 21, 2026St. Louis Cardinals2–6Pittsburgh Pirates

Season so far

St. Louis Cardinals are 19th of 30 on win rate after 157 games (76-81).

Pittsburgh Pirates are 13th of 30 on win rate after 157 games (80-77).

#TeamPWLRuns
19St. Louis Cardinals1577681704:729
13Pittsburgh Pirates1578077750:719

Team season model

  • St. Louis Cardinals attack index 100: scoring level with the league average per game.
  • St. Louis Cardinals defence index 104: 4% more conceded per game than the league average.
  • Pittsburgh Pirates attack index 107: 7% more scoring per game than the league average.
  • Pittsburgh Pirates defence index 102: 2% more conceded per game than the league average.

Index 100 is the league average per game. Above 100 in attack means more scoring; below 100 in defence means fewer conceded.

Every pre-game read, free for 7 days

  • Key factors: the matchups and numbers that shape this game.
  • Player form: recent output from the players who matter most.
  • Team news: injuries and availability from the latest reports.
  • Analyst chat: ask follow-up questions about this game (All-Access).
Start your 7-day free trial→Get the app · Google Play

then from $4.99/mo billed yearly

GET IT ONGoogle PlayCOMING SOONApp Store

More MLB games that day

  • Washington Nationals vs Detroit TigersSep 23, 2026 · 4–2
  • Minnesota Twins vs San Francisco GiantsSep 23, 2026 · 4–2
  • Toronto Blue Jays vs Baltimore OriolesSep 23, 2026 · 2–4
  • Milwaukee Brewers vs Philadelphia PhilliesSep 23, 2026 · 4–1
  • Tampa Bay Rays vs New York YankeesSep 23, 2026 · 2–9
  • Cleveland Guardians vs Boston Red SoxSep 23, 2026 · 0–1
  • Cincinnati Reds vs Atlanta BravesSep 23, 2026 · 2–3
  • Chicago White Sox vs Kansas City RoyalsSep 23, 2026 · 4–5
  • All MLB games →
  • St. Louis Cardinals: form and fixtures →
  • Pittsburgh Pirates: form and fixtures →
  • Baseball today →
SPORTANALYSTKnow the game before kickoff. For information and entertainment only.
HomePrivacyTerms