SPORTANALYST
FootballBaseballBasketballIce hockey
ENFRDE
  1. Home
  2. NHL
  3. New York Islanders vs Toronto Maple Leafs

New York Islanders 4–1 Toronto Maple Leafs: match recap

NYINew York IslandersLWLWL4
TMLToronto Maple LeafsLLWLW1

FinalNHL · Puck drop Oct 17, 2026, 11:00 PM UTC

New York Islanders and Toronto Maple Leafs finished 4–1 (NHL) on October 17, 2026. Below: the form, standings and head-to-head record both teams took into the game.

Start your 7-day free trial→Get the app · Google Play

then from $4.99/mo billed yearly

FREE RECAP

Match recap

The New York Islanders leaned on a balanced attack and a 76.7% model share to shut down a short-handed Maple Leafs side, rolling to a 4-1 win in Toronto. Anthony Duclair and Simon Holmstrom each found the back of the net, while the Islanders' defensive structure neutralized a Leafs lineup missing several regulars.

The Islanders struck early and never looked back, jumping out to a multi-goal lead in the opening frame. Bo Horvat orchestrated the offense with a goal and an assist, while Simon Holmstrom potted two goals to pace the attack. The Maple Leafs, playing without John Tavares, Miles Wood, Chris Tanev, and Dakota Joshua per the injury report, mustered only a single tally from C. Sissons. The Islanders' structure and discipline, coupled with the Leafs' depleted lineup, made the 4-1 scoreline a fair reflection of the night's play.

Key factors

  • NYI's scoring depth: Holmstrom's two goals and Horvat's multi-point night overwhelmed a Toronto defense missing key personnel.
  • Injury-depleted Toronto lineup: The Leafs entered without Tavares, Wood, Tanev, and Joshua, severely limiting their offensive options.
  • Model share dominance: NYI commanded a 76.7% share on the season-form comparison, underlining a wide gap in current form.

The Analyst's take

This was a game defined by depth versus attrition. The Islanders' ability to roll four lines and generate offense from multiple sources made the difference against a Maple Leafs team that was clearly missing its core contributors. Looking ahead, Toronto will need to survive this injury stretch with structure and goaltending, while the Islanders can build on this road performance as a template for their identity.

Matchup comparison

Even on form: both teams went 2-3 in their last 5 games.

Matchup to watch: New York Islanders’ attack (index 91) against Toronto Maple Leafs’ defence (index 111).

Matchup to watch: Toronto Maple Leafs’ attack (index 111) against New York Islanders’ defence (index 77).

Recent form: last 5

New York Islanders: 2 wins and 3 losses in the last 5, with 13 goals scored and 15 conceded.

New York Islanders
Oct 15, 2026at Ottawa SenatorsL1–2
Oct 13, 2026vs Vancouver CanucksW3–2
Oct 10, 2026vs Tampa Bay LightningL3–5
Oct 8, 2026vs Chicago BlackhawksW4–1
Oct 6, 2026at New York RangersL2–5

Toronto Maple Leafs: 2 wins and 3 losses in the last 5, with 22 goals scored and 21 conceded.

Toronto Maple Leafs
Oct 15, 2026vs Buffalo SabresL4–5
Oct 14, 2026at Utah MammothL4–5
Oct 10, 2026at Colorado AvalancheW6–3
Oct 9, 2026at Vegas Golden KnightsL3–4
Oct 6, 2026vs Nashville PredatorsW5–4

Results before kickoff, newest first.

Head-to-head

In the last 4 meetings on record, New York Islanders won 3, Toronto Maple Leafs won 1.

Sep 30, 2026Toronto Maple Leafs2–1New York Islanders
Apr 9, 2026 · last seasonNew York Islanders5–3Toronto Maple Leafs
Mar 17, 2026 · last seasonToronto Maple Leafs1–3New York Islanders
Jan 4, 2026 · last seasonNew York Islanders4–3Toronto Maple Leafs

Season so far

New York Islanders are 21st of 32 on win rate after 7 games (3-4).

Toronto Maple Leafs are 26th of 32 on win rate after 8 games (3-5).

#TeamPWLGoals
21New York Islanders73420:17
26Toronto Maple Leafs83528:28

Team season model

  • New York Islanders attack index 91: 9% less scoring per game than the league average.
  • New York Islanders defence index 77: 23% less conceded per game than the league average.
  • Toronto Maple Leafs attack index 111: 11% more scoring per game than the league average.
  • Toronto Maple Leafs defence index 111: 11% more conceded per game than the league average.

Index 100 is the league average per game. Above 100 in attack means more scoring; below 100 in defence means fewer conceded.

Every pre-game read, free for 7 days

  • Key factors: the matchups and numbers that shape this game.
  • Player form: recent output from the players who matter most.
  • Team news: injuries and availability from the latest reports.
  • Analyst chat: ask follow-up questions about this game (All-Access).
Start your 7-day free trial→Get the app · Google Play

then from $4.99/mo billed yearly

GET IT ONGoogle PlayIPHONE · COMPUTEROpen the web app

More NHL games that day

  • Pittsburgh Penguins vs Colorado AvalancheOct 17, 2026 · 2–5
  • Boston Bruins vs Anaheim DucksOct 17, 2026 · 4–2
  • New Jersey Devils vs Washington CapitalsOct 17, 2026 · 2–4
  • Carolina Hurricanes vs Winnipeg JetsOct 17, 2026 · 3–2
  • Vancouver Canucks vs Tampa Bay LightningOct 17, 2026 · 2–4
  • Seattle Kraken vs Florida PanthersOct 17, 2026 · 3–8
  • Buffalo Sabres vs Montreal CanadiensOct 17, 2026 · 3–4
  • Dallas Stars vs Chicago BlackhawksOct 17, 2026 · 4–0
  • All NHL games →
  • New York Islanders: form and fixtures →
  • Toronto Maple Leafs: form and fixtures →
  • Ice hockey today →
SPORTANALYSTKnow the game before kickoff.
HomePrivacyTermsCompare apps